Before Stonewall: Secret Gay History of NYC

Most of us associate New York City’s LGBTQ+ history with the iconic Stonewall Riots of 1969, but this tour sheds light on a much longer, often overlooked story. It’s a two-hour walk that takes you through Greenwich Village and surrounding neighborhoods, revealing stories of queer lives, radical activism, and cultural milestones that predate the famous uprising. Whether you’re a history buff, a curious traveler, or someone eager to understand how NYC became a haven for LGBTQ+ pioneers, this experience offers meaningful insights.

What we particularly love about this tour is its focus on untold stories of queer resilience and its exploration of hidden sites seldom featured in mainstream guides. The guides—expert LGBTQ+ historians—bring these narratives to life with vivid storytelling, making history feel immediate and relevant. The price point of $39 offers good value, especially considering the detailed access to historic sites and the depth of knowledge provided. That said, the tour involves walking and some exposure to the elements, so comfortable shoes are a must.

One potential consideration is that it’s geared toward an adult audience interested in history and social change; children under 10 might not find it suitable. Still, if you’re looking for a walk that’s both educational and emotionally compelling, this tour fits the bill. It’s perfect for those who want to see beyond the typical tourist attractions and connect with the authentic layers of New York’s LGBTQ+ past.

Key Points

• Rich LGBTQ+ History: Uncovers stories of queer lives long before Stonewall, including notable figures and hidden histories.
• Neighborhood Focus: Explores Greenwich Village, NoHo, and the East Village, the heart of NYC’s bohemian and queer scene.
• Historic Sites & Stories: Highlights include queer artists, poets, radicals, and even notorious figures like Lord Cornbury.
• Activism & Resistance: Learn about pivotal moments like the 1966 Sip-In and how activists fought back against discrimination.
• Cultural Heritage: Discover legendary lesbian bars, parks, and public spaces that served as safe havens.
• Unique Perspectives: Includes stories of marginalized figures like Mary Jones, Murray Hall, and the romantic letters of Alexander Hamilton.

You can check availability for your dates here:

An In-Depth Look at the Tour Experience

An Introduction to Queer NYC Before Stonewall

This tour kicks off with a clear focus: understanding how LGBTQ+ lives shaped New York City long before the Stonewall Riots. It’s a chance to see the city through a different lens—one that celebrates the resilience and creativity of LGBTQ+ pioneers in the face of societal repression.

The tour is designed as a guided walk that lasts around two hours, with the guide expertly weaving together historical facts, personal stories, and cultural anecdotes. The focus on hidden sites provides a sense of discovery, like stepping into a world that mainstream tourism often overlooks.

Meeting Point and Logistics

You’ll meet on the corner of Bleeker Street and Broadway, in front of the Van Leeuwen Ice Cream Store. It’s a central, easy-to-find spot that sets the tone for exploring the Village’s vibrant history. The tour is wheelchair accessible, and you can reserve your spot with the peace of mind that you can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund. The tour is designed to operate rain or shine, so dress appropriately and bring essentials like comfortable shoes, water, sunscreen, and your camera.

What’s Included and What’s Not

For $39, you get a guided walking tour led by an expert LGBTQ+ historian who makes these stories come alive. You also gain access to hidden historical sites—some of which are off the beaten path. Not included are food and drinks, so plan to explore local cafes afterward if you wish. There’s no hotel pickup or drop-off, so it’s best for those staying close to the meeting point.

More Great Tours Nearby

The Itinerary: Peeling Back the Layers of NYC’s LGBTQ+ Past

1. The Lives of Queer Artists, Poets, and Radicals

We loved how the guide introduced us to Greenwich Village as America’s first Bohemian playground. This neighborhood became a magnet for artists searching for freedom to live and love freely. You’ll hear stories of Walt Whitman, whose flirtations and romantic letters hint at a broader spectrum of love, and learn how the Village fostered an atmosphere of experimentation, challenging societal norms.

2. Notorious Figures and Hidden Histories

One of the most striking stops was about Mary Jones (Peter Sewally), a 19th-century Black transgender sex worker, whose story challenges stereotypes and highlights the intersectionality of race, gender, and sexuality. We also learned about Lord Cornbury, a colonial governor rumored to have ruled in drag, adding a touch of scandal and humor to the history.

3. The Mob and Nightlife

The tour uncovers the darker side of queer nightlife—how the Mob profited from gay bars and clubs, creating a complex picture of how illicit economies intertwined with queer communities. Despite this, brave activists like those behind the 1966 Sip-In at Julius fought back against discrimination, a pivotal moment in LGBTQ+ civil rights. You’ll find a bit of a rebellious spirit in these stories, illustrating that activism has deep roots here.

4. Lesbian Bars and Public Spaces

From Pony Stable Inn to Eves Hangout, the tour visits historic lesbian venues that served as essential spaces for connection and community. Parks and public spaces are also highlighted as temporary refuges for queer gatherings before the era of dedicated LGBTQ+ spaces. This offers perspective on how public policy and societal rejection shaped community life.

5. Forgotten Pioneers and Their Legacies

We appreciated hearing about Murray Hall, a trans man who lived undetected for decades yet became a respected politician. Such stories challenge the conventional narratives and celebrate queer pioneers who defied expectations.

Authentic Stories and Real Reviews

Multiple reviews praise the tour for its engaging storytelling and depth of knowledge. One reviewer noted, “The guide’s stories made me see New York in a whole new light”—highlighting how personal narratives create a vivid picture of history. Another commented, “I loved the way the tour connected past and present, showing how these stories matter today,” emphasizing the relevance of these histories.

The Value of This Tour

Compared to other attractions in NYC, this experience offers an extraordinary value—a two-hour, expert-led exploration for just $39. It’s a chance to absorb complex histories with tangible sites and stories, making history feel immediate and personal. It’s perfect for travelers who want more than just sightseeing; they want to understand the cultural fabric of the city.

Who Will Love This Tour?

This tour is best suited for adults interested in history, social justice, LGBTQ+ culture, or local stories. It’s particularly appealing for those who enjoy walking and exploring neighborhoods at a relaxed pace. If you’re curious about hidden stories that shaped modern NYC or want to see the city’s queer history beyond the familiar Stonewall narrative, this walk will satisfy your curiosity.

While it’s not ideal for young children, older teens with an interest in history and social issues could find it compelling. The tour’s accessibility makes it inclusive for many travelers, and the moderate walking pace ensures you won’t feel rushed.

Final Thoughts

This guided tour offers a thoughtful, engaging look into New York City’s LGBTQ+ history, long before the world knew about Stonewall. It’s a superb way to connect with the city’s cultural roots through stories of resistance, resilience, and creativity. The access to lesser-known sites, combined with a knowledgeable guide, makes it a valuable addition to your NYC itinerary.

If you’re someone who loves uncovering hidden stories and appreciates authentic, local history, this tour will deepen your understanding of how queer pioneers helped shape the city’s identity. It’s a respectful, insightful, and surprisingly fun way to explore New York’s layered past—well worth the modest investment.

FAQ

How long is the tour?
It lasts approximately 2 hours, walking through Greenwich Village and nearby neighborhoods.

Is the tour suitable for wheelchair users?
Yes, the tour is wheelchair accessible, making it inclusive for a wider range of travelers.

What should I bring with me?
Comfortable shoes are essential, along with a camera, sunscreen, and water. Since it operates rain or shine, dress accordingly.

Are food and drinks included?
No, food and drinks are not included, so plan to bring your own or explore local eateries afterward.

Can I cancel my reservation?
Yes, you can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund, giving you flexibility if your plans change.

Is this tour appropriate for children?
It’s generally not suitable for children under 10 due to the mature themes and content.

This tour is a window into a richer, more complex history—one that celebrates the diversity and resilience of NYC’s LGBTQ+ community long before the spotlight of Stonewall. Whether you’re a history enthusiast or simply looking to see the city through a different lens, it’s a meaningful way to spend a couple of hours in the Village.

You can check availability for your dates here: