Edinburgh: The Lost Close Underground Scotch Whiskey Tasting

If you’re visiting Edinburgh and looking for a way to combine history, local culture, and a splash of Scotland’s famous spirit, the Underground Scotch Whisky Tasting at The Lost Close offers a compelling choice. Although we haven’t personally taken this tour, the reviews and descriptions paint a vivid picture of an engaging and memorable experience — set in a secret, atmospheric underground venue that’s as steeped in history as the whisky itself.

What excites us most about this experience is the combination of an intimate, atmospheric setting and the opportunity to taste whiskies from all the major Scottish regions. The underground vaults provide a sense of stepping back in time, and the knowledgeable guides make the history of Scotch come alive with stories and humor. Plus, the option to upgrade your tasting to include rarer or more prestigious drams means you can tailor the experience to your level of enthusiasm or expertise.

One thing to keep in mind is that the tour runs for about 1.5 hours and involves some walking and standing. It’s not suited for everyone — particularly those with mobility issues or children — but for adults who enjoy a good story and a fine dram, this experience hits the right notes. It’s especially perfect for travelers with an interest in whisky, history, or unique local venues.

In sum, this tour is best suited for curious visitors eager for a relaxed, in-depth introduction to Scotch whisky in a setting that’s both authentic and atmospheric. Whether you’re a whisky novice or a seasoned enthusiast, you’ll find value here — especially thanks to the friendly guides, the variety of whisky from different regions, and the special underground ambiance.

Key Points

• Unique underground venue in historic Edinburgh adds an authentic and atmospheric touch.
• Guided tastings include whiskies from all major Scottish regions, providing a well-rounded experience.
• Option to upgrade to rarer, older, or high-end drams for a more exclusive tasting.
• Engaging guides share stories and history, making the experience both fun and educational.
• Short duration (1.5 hours) makes it a perfect addition to a busy sightseeing day.
• Accessible only to those over 18, no food included, but it’s an excellent complement to exploring the city’s history.

You can check availability for your dates here:

Discovering the Underground Vaults of Edinburgh

Walking into the Lost Close feels like entering a secret place, hidden beneath Edinburgh’s bustling Royal Mile. The underground vaults, recently uncovered, serve as the perfect backdrop for a whisky tasting that’s as much about Scotland’s heritage as it is about flavor.

Your journey begins at Johns Coffee House & Tavern, part of the CoDE Hostel, where your guide will meet you. From there, you follow your guide through a short walk behind the Mercat Cross, past the James Braidwood statue, into the underground world where centuries of Edinburgh’s history are layered in stone and shadow.

This initial walk sets the tone — a mix of anticipation and curiosity. The vaults themselves have a rugged charm, with their stone walls and dim lighting creating a cozy, almost clandestine atmosphere. It’s a stark contrast to the bustling streets above and instantly elevates the experience from a typical tasting to an adventure.

What to Expect During the Tour

The tour is divided into two main parts: a guided walk through The Lost Close (about 20 minutes), followed by the whisky tasting session (approximately 70 minutes). The guide’s stories bring the space and the whisky to life, blending history, folklore, and practical tidbits.

The Guided Tour in The Lost Close

While brief, the guided walk is packed with interesting tidbits about Edinburgh’s history and the vaults themselves. You learn how these underground spaces have been used over the centuries — from homeless shelters to clandestine meetings. The atmosphere is intimate, and guides often entertain with amusing tales about the characters who’ve walked these halls, adding depth and personality to your experience.

The Whisky Tasting

Once in the vaults, the real fun begins. You’re served four different whiskies, each representing a different major region of Scotland. Your guide explains the characteristics of each, helping you recognize the subtle differences in flavor, aroma, and texture. It’s a good primer for anyone new to whisky or an excellent refresher for seasoned drinkers.

The standard tasting features four well-chosen whiskies, but you can upgrade to intermediate or high-end options. The intermediate upgrade offers rarer, older whiskies that are hard to find elsewhere, adding a sense of exclusivity. The high-end selection boasts top-shelf drams that would typically be reserved for connoisseurs and collectors. One reviewer noted, “Our guide was more than happy to customize the tasting to my preferences,” which shows how flexible and personalized this experience can be.

More Great Tours Nearby

The Guide’s Role

The guides are frequently praised for their knowledge, humor, and enthusiasm. Multiple reviews highlight guides like Nickey and Eleanor, who are described as friendly, witty, and full of interesting facts. One reviewer said, “Nickey was fantastic — answered all our questions, very informed, and a whiskey lover herself,” emphasizing the value of having a passionate expert at your side.

The Regional Whisky Sampling

The tour’s structure exposes guests to whiskies from Lowland, Highland, Speyside, and Islay, offering a broad taste of Scotland’s diversity. Each region produces distinct styles, and your guide will help you appreciate these differences. For example, Speyside whiskies are often sweet and fruity, while Islay drams tend toward peaty and smoky.

Guests report that this regional approach provides a comprehensive introduction to Scotch whisky, making it easier to understand and identify flavors if you choose to explore further later on.

The Value of Upgrading Your Tasting

The option to upgrade your whisky experience is a standout feature. Rarer and older drams, as well as top-shelf selections, are typically more expensive and difficult to find in regular shops. The upgrade provides not only a more luxurious tasting but also a chance to savor some exclusive bottles, making it a worthwhile investment for enthusiasts.

One reviewer noted, “I chose the premium whisky, and the host was more than happy to customize the tasting,” which highlights the flexibility and personalized nature of the experience.

Timing, Group Size, and Practicalities

The duration of 1.5 hours makes this a perfect activity to slot into a day of sightseeing without feeling rushed. The small group setting ensures personalized attention, making it ideal for those who prefer an intimate, relaxed environment.

Meeting at Johns Coffee House & Tavern is convenient, and the tour ends right back where it started. The tour is conducted in English, and no food is included, so plan to have dinner afterward if you’re hungry.

Transport isn’t included, so it’s best to arrive on foot or via public transit. The experience is not suitable for children under 18, pregnant women, or wheelchair users, due to the underground setting and alcohol regulations.

Authenticity and Atmosphere

The underground vaults create an authentic Scottish ambiance that no other venue can match. Many reviewers mention how the setting enhances the tasting, creating an experience that’s both educational and atmospheric. Several comment on the atmospheric surroundings and the storytelling, which make the whole event memorable.

Overall Value and Recommendations

Considering the reviews, this tour offers excellent value for money, especially if you opt for the upgrade. The combination of knowledgeable guides, atmospheric setting, and regional whiskies makes it stand out among Edinburgh’s many whisky-related activities.

For travelers who love stories, history, or whisky itself, this experience delivers a well-rounded, engaging, and fun introduction to Scotland’s national drink. The small-group format and opportunity to upgrade make it flexible for different preferences and budgets.

Who Should Book This Tour?

This experience appeals most to adults with a curiosity for whisky or Scottish history. It’s ideal for those who enjoy learning through storytelling and want a tasting experience outside the usual bar or distillery tour. It’s also great for travelers seeking something unique, intimate, and atmospheric — especially if they appreciate a good story and a well-curated selection of whiskies.

If you’re interested in a relaxed, authentic taste of Edinburgh’s underground heritage combined with premium whisky options, this is a memorable choice. Just remember, it’s a drinking experience, so be prepared to enjoy and relax.

FAQs

Is the tour suitable for children?
No, the tour is only for those over 18, as it involves alcohol tasting.

Does the tour include transportation?
No, transportation isn’t included. You’ll meet at Johns Coffee House & Tavern, which is easy to access from central Edinburgh.

How long does the tour last?
The experience is approximately 1.5 hours, including the guided walk and tasting.

Can I choose a different whisky tasting level?
Yes, during booking you can opt for the standard, intermediate, or high-end tasting, depending on your interest and budget.

What if I want to do a private or custom experience?
The reviews suggest guides are happy to customize the tasting, especially if you upgrade, but the experience is generally designed for small groups.

Is there any food included?
No, food isn’t included, but you might want to eat before or after the tour.

Is the venue accessible for wheelchair users?
No, the underground vaults are not suitable for wheelchair access.

What should I wear?
Dress comfortably; there’s no strict dress code, but consider the underground setting and wear layers if needed.

What is the best way to prepare for the tasting?
Come with an open mind and curiosity. It’s a relaxed session, so enjoy the stories and flavors.

Final Thoughts

The Underground Scotch Whisky Tasting at The Lost Close offers a rare blend of history, atmosphere, and flavor. Set in Edinburgh’s secret vaults, it’s a chance to connect with Scotland’s whisky heritage in a way that feels both personal and immersive. Guides are praised for their knowledge and humor, making the experience both educational and entertaining.

For those who enjoy learning about regional differences in whisky, savoring quality drams, and exploring Edinburgh’s hidden history, this tour is a genuine highlight. While it’s not suited for young children or those with mobility constraints, it provides a rich, flavorful taste of Scotland’s national drink — wrapped in an authentic setting that elevates the simple act of tasting into a memorable adventure.

Whether you’re a whisky newcomer or a seasoned enthusiast, this underground journey promises a spirited glimpse into Scotland’s finest tradition — all in a venue that’s as captivating as the whisky itself.

You can check availability for your dates here: