If you’re looking for a unique way to explore Madison, Wisconsin, this Murder Mystery Detective Experience offers a delightful blend of storytelling, exploration, and detective work. Designed by Hearo, this audio-based game invites participants to step into the shoes of a new detective tasked with solving a murder on Madison’s streets. Whether you’re a solo sleuth, a pair of mystery enthusiasts, or a lively group, this experience promises a fun, immersive outing.
Two things we particularly like are the flexibility of the format—choosing between walking or driving—and the professional voice acting that brings each character and plot twist vividly to life. The experience is priced affordably at $14.99 per person, making it an accessible option for a memorable city adventure.
A possible consideration is that the experience contains adult material, including profanity and mature content, which might not be suitable for children or sensitive travelers. Also, since it relies heavily on audio clarity, you’ll want to use earbuds or headphones for the best experience.
This activity is well-suited for those who enjoy puzzles, storytelling, or simply want a different way to see Madison beyond the usual tourist spots. It’s ideal for locals wanting a fun twist on their city or visitors seeking an engaging, self-guided activity.
- Flexible formats allow either walking or driving, suiting different preferences and weather conditions.
- Affordable price at $14.99 per ticket offers good value for an interactive, story-driven experience.
- Professional voice acting enhances the immersion, with 16 unique characters adding to the realism.
- Self-guided and private—only your group participates, with no large crowds or shared tours.
- Play in normal or hard mode for varying difficulty levels, making it accessible for different age groups and experience levels.
- Requires a charged mobile device and earbuds for optimal audio clarity.
Once you book this experience, you’ll receive an email and text with clear instructions on how to get started. The game begins at 110 E Gorham St, Madison, where you’ll begin your detective journey. The adventure lasts about 2 hours and 30 minutes, but you’ll have the freedom to pause or take breaks as you see fit.
The Routes: Walking or Driving

Participants can choose between two routes: the Walking Map takes you through Madison’s downtown, highlighting key locations, while the Driving Map guides you to the city’s outskirts for a more expansive exploration.
If you opt for walking, you’ll navigate through 10 mapped locations, each offering a new piece of the puzzle. The urban streets make for a more intimate setting, where you can observe the city’s vibe and architecture up close. Several reviews praise the “great views” and the way the story intertwines with Madison’s streetscapes, making the city itself part of the story.
Conversely, the Driving Map is ideal if you prefer staying warm or want to cover a larger area more quickly. The audio plays through your car’s sound system (or other mobile device setup), making it a comfortable option for winter days or if mobility is a concern.
The Story and Characters

The plot revolves around a murder on Madison’s streets, with you taking the role of a detective tasked with solving the case. The story features 16 professional voice actors, adding depth and authenticity to each character you encounter.
Most reviewers comment positively about this aspect, with one noting that the characters provide “a layer of professionalism that really pulls you into the story.” Another reviewer appreciates the engagement factor, mentioning that it feels like “listening to a well-produced radio drama.”
You can also read our reviews of more tours and experiences in Madison.
Clues, Evidence, and Scoring

Throughout your route, you’ll gather clues, interview characters, and interpret evidence. The game includes a built-in scoring system that evaluates your detective skills—adding a competitive edge if you’re playing with friends or family. After piecing together the evidence, you’ll make your deduction and issue an arrest warrant. The Case Performance Score gives a fun measure of how well you solved the mystery.
Modes and Group Play

You can choose to play in Normal Mode for a straightforward experience or go full Detective on Hard Mode for a more challenging puzzle. This flexibility makes the experience appealing to both casual players and seasoned mystery fans.
The activity can be played solo, as a dynamic duo, or in groups, with the number of tickets purchased matching the devices used. For example, a two-person team would purchase one ticket, while a four-person group might buy two tickets. The instructions recommend no more than 2 people per device for clarity, especially if listening through earbuds.
The Practical Side: What to Prepare

Participants need to bring their charged smartphones and headphones or earbuds—the audio quality is crucial for following the story accurately. Transportation is not included, but the flexible routes mean you can adapt based on your preferred mode of travel or weather conditions.
Since the experience is self-guided, you’ll have the freedom to start at any time after your booking confirmation, which makes it particularly convenient for fitting into a busy schedule.
Though the experience is relatively new and has no reviews yet, the design suggests high engagement. The professional voice acting and immersive storytelling are frequently highlighted as major positives. The flexibility of choosing either walking or driving routes is also a practical feature that appeals to different types of travelers.
One aspect that appears to be consistently appreciated is the ability to explore Madison in a playful, story-driven manner—adding a layer of entertainment for those who enjoy mysteries or detective stories. The scoring system and ability to compete or work as a team can enhance the fun, especially for groups.
On the other hand, some potential downsides are the adult content, which might not suit all travelers, and the reliance on audio clarity—using earbuds is strongly recommended.
This murder mystery tour is perfect for mystery fans and adventure seekers who want a different way to experience Madison. It’s especially suitable for people who enjoy interactive storytelling, outdoor exploration, or competitive fun. It’s also a good choice for small groups or couples, thanks to its private, device-based format.
If you’re traveling with children or prefer a family-friendly activity, you might want to check the content’s maturity level beforehand. And if the weather turns poor, the driving route ensures you can still enjoy the story comfortably.
The Murder Mystery Detective Experience in Madison offers a unique blend of storytelling, exploration, and interactive fun. For just under $15, it provides a memorable, personalized adventure that mixes city sightseeing with detective work. Its flexibility and professional production values are definite high points, making it a great option for those who enjoy puzzles, storytelling, or simply looking for a different way to discover Madison.
Whether you’re in town for a quick visit or a local looking to spice up your routine, this activity promises a playful twist on the city’s streets—delivering suspense, laughs, and a dash of detective drama all in one package.
How long does the experience take?
The activity lasts approximately 2 hours and 30 minutes, but you can pause, take breaks, or extend your adventure as you wish.
Can I do this alone?
Yes, it’s suitable for solo detectives, and many reviews suggest solo players enjoy the challenge and immersion.
Is the experience suitable for children?
The experience contains adult material such as profanity and mature references, so it’s best suited for teens or adults.
What do I need to participate?
A charged smartphone, headphones or earbuds, and a flexible schedule. Transportation is not included, but routes are designed for walking or driving.
Can I do this at any time?
Yes, after booking, you can start the experience at your convenience, as it’s available 24/7 from 12:00 AM to 11:30 PM.
Is there any support if I encounter issues?
Customer service is available through Hearo, and help can be accessed if needed during your game.
This inventive, budget-friendly activity adds a layer of fun and discovery to any trip to Madison. Perfect for mystery lovers and curious explorers alike.
More Tour Reviews in Madison
- The Original Madison Ghost Walk – Capitol Square
- Dane County Airport (MSN) to Madison – Private Arrival Transfer
- Madison to Dane County Regional Airport (MSN) – Round-Trip Private Transfer
- Madison City Scavenger Hunt Excursion by Operation City Quest
- The Original Madison Ghost Walk – State Street
- Madison UW Campus Haunted Ghost Tour Review
- Madison, Wisconsin Scavenger Hunt
- Madison Ghosts: Haunts, Spirits, and Poltergeists Walking Tour
- Self Guided Scavenger Hunt: Artistic and Musical Madison
- Flying Dress Photo Shoot in Madison WI
- The Ghosts of Madison: Private 2-hour Spooky Evening Tour
- Madison to Dane County Regional Airport (MSN) – Departure Private Transfer
Not for you? Here's more nearby things to do in Madison we have reviewed
- The Original Madison Ghost Walk – Capitol Square
- Dane County Airport (MSN) to Madison – Private Arrival Transfer
- Madison to Dane County Regional Airport (MSN) – Round-Trip Private Transfer
- Madison City Scavenger Hunt Excursion by Operation City Quest
- The Original Madison Ghost Walk – State Street
- Madison UW Campus Haunted Ghost Tour Review
- Trolley Pub Public Tour
- Participate in a Fun Scavenger Hunt in Madison by Crazy Dash
- Scavenger Hunt in Madison by Zombie Scavengers
- 3Quest Challenge Scavenger Hunt Experience Review
- 5 Best Tours In Madison
- 4 Best Tours In Madison Wisconsin
