New York: Broadway Comedy Club All Star Stand-Up Comedy Live

Our review focuses on the Broadway Comedy Club All Star Stand-Up Comedy Live—a popular choice for those craving a good laugh in New York. While we haven’t attended ourselves, the consistent glowing reviews and detailed descriptions paint a picture of a lively, comedic evening perfect for travelers looking to unwind after sightseeing or those eager to see talented comedians without breaking the bank.

What makes this experience stand out? First, the lineup of comics who have appeared on Netflix, Hulu, and Saturday Night Live—you’re getting stand-up from some of the best in the business, right in the heart of Manhattan. Second, the venue’s intimacy ensures you’re close enough to see every expression and nuance, making the show feel personal and energetic.

A potential consideration is the two-drink minimum, which can add up, especially if you’re not a big drinker or are traveling with kids (not suitable under 12). But overall, this is a lively, authentic comedy experience that offers great value for the price.

This show is ideal for adults and mature teens who want to enjoy NYC’s comedy scene without the high price tag or the hassle of big theater productions. If you love stand-up, enjoy discovering new comedians, or want a relaxed night out near Times Square, this is a solid choice.

Key Points

• Top-Level Comedy: Comedians who have appeared on major TV platforms, ensuring high-quality humor.
• Intimate Setting: All seats are close to the stage, creating a personal and lively atmosphere.
• Near Times Square: Located in the vibrant Broadway Theater District, perfect for combining with other evening plans.
• Two Drink Minimum: Expect to purchase at least two drinks; alcohol is available but not required.
• Surprise Drop-ins: Each night features guest comedians, adding spontaneity to the show.
• Affordable Price: At $25, it offers good value compared to many other NYC entertainment options.

From the moment you step into the Broadway Comedy Club, you’re entering a space renowned for comedy talent and a welcoming vibe. The venue’s intimate size means no one is far from the action, with all seats offering a clear view of the stage and the expressive comedians. This close proximity amplifies the energy—laughter bounces off the walls, and you feel part of the show.

The lineup features top headliners from Netflix, Comedy Central, Hulu, and HBO, often with special guest comics who drop in unpredictably. This element of surprise keeps the evening fresh and lively, as the performers might vary from night to night. According to reviews, the quality of comedians generally exceeds expectations, with many guests noting that the opening acts are especially strong.

The show lasts about 1.5 hours, which is ideal for a night out without feeling overly long or rushed. The performance typically starts in the evening, but check your ticket details for time slots that suit your schedule.

You can check availability for your dates here:

What about the drinks?

Each ticket includes entry, but there is a two-drink minimum—both alcoholic and non-alcoholic options are available. Some reviewers mention the cost of drinks can be steep, with beer around $11 and cocktails more expensive. If you’re watching your budget, you might choose to stick with just the show or share a drink to keep things affordable.

The Comedy Lineup: Who You Might See

The comics are drawn from major comedy circuits and have appeared on well-known platforms. That means you’ll likely see a mix of up-and-coming talents and established performers. Some audience reviews mention that certain comedians can be harder to follow due to dialects or style, but overall, the humor lands well with most.

Accessibility and Practicalities

The venue is wheelchair accessible and you can enter up to 30 minutes before showtime. This flexibility is handy for travelers with tight schedules or mobility needs.

The Atmosphere and Audience

Many reviews point to a laid-back, casual environment ideal for unwinding. While some find the seating arrangement a bit crowded or the venue needing a slight refresh, the overall vibe is fun and friendly. It’s a place where locals and travelers alike gather for a night of genuine laughter.

More Great Tours Nearby

Value for Money

At just $25, this ticket is a sound investment for quality entertainment that leaves you laughing without the hefty price tag of Broadway shows or high-end clubs. The two-drink minimum does add to the cost, but most find it reasonable considering the quality of talent. Several reviews praise the good value, especially when compared to other options in NYC.

The Reviews Speak Volumes

• Many guests loved the diversity of comedians—some highlighted that the opening acts were particularly strong.
• A few comments note that drink prices can be high, but they don’t detract from the overall enjoyment.
• Several reviews mention the close seating and friendly staff making for a memorable night.
• Some guests felt that certain comedians could be a bit edgy or material might be uneven, but that’s part of the charm—comedy is subjective.

Who Will This Suit Best?

This experience is perfect for adults who enjoy stand-up comedy and want a casual, authentic NYC entertainment option. It’s especially good if you’re staying near Times Square or the Broadway Theater District and want to add a night of laughter to your itinerary. Young travelers, couples, or groups of friends will appreciate the relaxed vibe, while comedy enthusiasts will enjoy the chance to see comedians on the rise, as well as established acts.

Yes, if you’re looking for a lively night out without splurging. The Broadway Comedy Club offers a funny, engaging, and intimate experience that captures the spirit of New York’s comedy scene. The lineup of TV-star comedians and the close-up experience make it a memorable choice.

However, be prepared for the two-drink minimum and the potential for some comedy material to be a bit edgy or uneven—just like in any comedy club. If you’re after a relaxed, authentically New York comedy night, this is a dependable option with consistent praise.

This show is ideal for adults who want to laugh, explore the city’s entertainment options, or finish their evening just steps from Times Square.

Is this show suitable for children?
No, it’s recommended for guests over 12 years old, as some material and humor might not be appropriate for younger audiences.

How long does the show last?
The performance typically runs for about 1.5 hours, sometimes stretching slightly longer.

Can I arrive early?
Yes, you can enter up to 30 minutes before the show begins, which allows for some relaxed seating and settling in.

Are drinks included in the price?
No, drinks are not included. There’s a mandatory two-drink minimum, with options ranging from non-alcoholic to alcoholic beverages.

Is the venue accessible?
Yes, the Broadway Comedy Club is wheelchair accessible.

What if I want to cancel?
You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund, making it flexible for your plans.

Are the comedians guaranteed to be the same every night?
No, the lineup can vary, especially with surprise guest comics dropping in nightly, which keeps each visit fresh.

Is the ticket price worth the experience?
Most reviews agree it is—especially given the high-quality comedians and intimate setting—making it a good deal for a memorable night in NYC.

To sum it up, if you’re after a fun, affordable, and authentic comedy night near Times Square, the Broadway Comedy Club delivers on all counts. Its mix of top TV comedians, spontaneous guest appearances, and a friendly, close-up environment make it a standout choice for those wanting to see a different side of New York’s entertainment scene. Whether you’re celebrating, relaxing, or just wanting a good laugh, this show offers solid value and a night you won’t forget.

You can check availability for your dates here: