NYC: Five Star Dining. All-Star Dueling Pianos.

Planning a night out that combines excellent food, lively music, and a little bit of theater? This experience offers just that—a four-hour journey into the heart of NYC’s most celebrated dueling pianos show, served up with some of the city’s finest steak and seafood. It’s a chance to enjoy a unique blend of culinary excellence and interactive entertainment, all in an intimate, underground setting that keeps it exclusive.

What makes this experience especially appealing? First, the dueling pianos show is the longest-running in New York City history, promising a lively, ever-changing repertoire that can include thousands of songs. Second, the restaurant—a top-rated steak and seafood venue—serves up a menu that’s as much a treat for the palate as the entertainment is for the ears. The downside? It’s an event that’s best suited for those who enjoy a lively, sometimes loud atmosphere and are willing to meet a food/beverage minimum. Still, if you’re after a fun, lively night with good food and great music, this experience checks all the boxes.

This tour is ideal for travelers who love interactive live entertainment, appreciate quality dining, and want to experience something authentically New York—an electrifying show set in a hidden, exclusive venue. If you’re seeking a night of laughs, sing-alongs, and spirited music in a memorable setting, this is a prime choice.

Key Points

• Unique Venue: The event takes place in an underground showroom at NYC’s acclaimed Hunt and Fish Club, adding an air of exclusivity.
• Long-Running Tradition: As the longest-running dueling pianos show in NYC, it’s a tried-and-true entertainment option.
• Extensive Song List: With thousands of songs available, no two shows are alike, keeping the experience fresh and engaging.
• Gourmet Dining: Enjoy crafted cocktails, signature burgers, and famous bread alongside your lively entertainment.
• All-Request Show: You have the chance to request your favorite tunes, making it a participatory experience.
• Limited Tickets: Only 50 tickets are available per event, ensuring an intimate, spirited atmosphere.

You can check availability for your dates here:

An In-Depth Look at the Experience

The Venue and Atmosphere

This experience takes place inside the exclusive underground showroom at the Hunt and Fish Club, located at 125 W 44th St inside the AKA Times Square Hotel. The setting is both elegant and intimate, designed to make you feel like you’re part of a special party rather than just a spectator. The limited number of tickets—only 50—helps maintain this cozy, energetic vibe, perfect for those who prefer a more personal, crowd-involved environment.

Arrival and Seating

Check-in is straightforward—just head to the host stand. Seating begins at 7 pm, with the show starting at 8:30 pm. The reserved table seating means you can settle in comfortably, ready for a four-hour evening filled with music, food, and fun. The early dinner seating allows you to maximize your time enjoying both the food and the performance without feeling rushed.

The Dueling Pianos Show

The core of this experience is the dueling pianos—two talented entertainers who trade off, take requests, and create a lively, spontaneous atmosphere. We loved the way the performers keep the energy high, encouraging sing-alongs and laughter. The fact that the show is never the same twice means you could revisit and still be surprised. Reviewers consistently note the large song catalog, with “thousands of songs to choose from,” ensuring everyone finds something to sing along with.

The show is interactive, with audience participation heavily encouraged. Guests love requesting their favorite tunes, and you might find yourself jumping up to sing or laugh along with others. One reviewer mentioned, “It’s a rock n roll party where everyone is part of the fun.” The performers are praised for their ability to keep the audience engaged, making it feel like a private party rather than a staged event.

More Great Tours Nearby

Food and Drink

The menu at Hunt and Fish Club is a highlight, boasting crafted cocktails, designer burgers, and their own famous bread. The food quality is typically rated highly; many reviews mention the bread as “famous,” and the menu offers a good variety of steak and seafood options.

A $40 minimum per guest for food and beverages applies, which encourages guests to indulge while enjoying the show. Expect a range of high-quality dishes, from succulent seafood to hearty steaks, paired with creative cocktails. The service charge of 20% is added on-site, which is standard for NYC upscale venues but should be factored into your overall budget.

How the Cost Adds Up

While the ticket price is $59 per person, that covers the entertainment and reserved seating. The food and drink minimum, plus gratuities, will likely bring your total closer to $100-150 per person, depending on your choices. For those seeking a lively, authentic NYC experience combining entertainment with fine dining, the value is solid—especially considering the exclusivity and historic nature of the show.

What Reviewers Say

Guests appreciate the interactive nature of the show. One review mentioned, “You get to sing along, laugh, and party with strangers in a cozy underground setting.” Others highlight the quality of the entertainment and the delicious food, noting that the atmosphere is more fun than formal—ideal for those looking for a relaxed, energetic evening.

Logistics and Practicalities

The event starts at 8:30 pm, with seating at 7 pm, which gives you ample time to enjoy a leisurely dinner. The limited number of tickets makes it essential to book in advance. Since cancellation is free up to 24 hours prior, you can plan with some flexibility. The show is suited for guests over 16, which makes it a good adult outing, but not ideal for families with young children.

Who Should Consider This Experience?

This is perfect for music lovers who enjoy a participatory atmosphere, foodies eager to indulge in NYC’s culinary scene, and adventurers looking for something uniquely local. It works especially well if you want an interactive, lively evening where you’re encouraged to sing and laugh along. Not ideal for those seeking a quiet, formal dinner or a more subdued entertainment experience.

Final Thoughts

This dueling pianos experience in NYC offers a compelling blend of high-quality dining and interactive entertainment. It’s a rare chance to enjoy a show with a storied history in a hidden, intimate setting, all while sampling some of the best steak and seafood the city has to offer. The participatory nature of the show makes it feel like a private party, and the food is well worth the extra expense for most guests.

While the event isn’t the cheapest night out in NYC, the value lies in the combination of exclusive venue, great music, and excellent food. It’s a memorable way to spend an evening if you’re looking for a fun, engaging experience that captures the spirit of New York—the city of endless surprises.

FAQ

How do I get tickets for this experience?
Tickets are limited to only 50 per event and are held under your name at will call. You should book in advance to secure your spot.

What is included in the ticket price?
The ticket covers your reserved table, entry to the show, and the all-request, sing-along performance.

Are there any additional costs?
Yes, there’s a required $40 minimum per guest for food and beverages, plus a 20% service charge added onsite. Gratuities for performers are optional.

What is the duration of the event?
The entire experience lasts about four hours, with seating beginning at 7 pm and the show starting at 8:30 pm.

Can I cancel my reservation?
Yes, cancellations are free if made 24 hours before the event, allowing some flexibility in your plans.

Is the event suitable for children?
It’s recommended for guests over 16, as the lively atmosphere and content may not be appropriate for younger children.

What kind of food can I expect?
The venue offers crafted cocktails, designer burgers, and their famous bread, with a focus on steak and seafood options.

Is this experience suitable for a romantic night out?
Absolutely—many couples enjoy the lively, interactive atmosphere combined with high-quality food.

How lively is the environment?
Very lively—expect singing, laughter, and participation, making it more of a party than a formal dinner.

In all, this experience offers a distinctive, fun way to enjoy NYC’s vibrant nightlife with a perfect blend of culinary delights and musical entertainment. It’s suited for those ready to sing along, share a few laughs, and indulge in top-tier food in a secret, exclusive setting.

You can check availability for your dates here: