If you’re looking for a lively, family-friendly activity in New York City that combines amazing magic tricks with a bit of comedy and audience interaction, the Broadway Magic Hour offers a neat option. This one-and-a-half-hour show at The Broadway Comedy Club near Times Square has earned solid praise for being fun for both kids and adults alike. While it’s not a high-stakes illusion show, it’s a great way to add some light-hearted entertainment to your NYC itinerary.
What makes this experience stand out? First, it’s affordable at around $25 per ticket, making it accessible for most families. Second, the show’s location near Times Square makes it easy to fit into a busy sightseeing day. On the downside, some visitors note that the tricks are familiar and scripted, but the engaging personalities of the magicians often keep the energy high.
This tour really suits families with kids, especially those aged 6 and up, looking for a safe, entertaining afternoon that can be enjoyed during inclement weather or when you need a break from walking. It’s also a wonderful way to introduce children to the magic arts in a professional setting that’s designed for all ages.
Key Points

- Family-friendly: Suitable for kids aged 6 and older, with audience participation making it interactive.
- Location: Near Times Square, perfect for fitting into a busy sightseeing schedule.
- Duration: 1 hour 30 minutes of light-hearted, engaging entertainment.
- Value: At $25, it offers a budget-friendly experience with lots of fun.
- Accessibility: ADA-compliant, with elevator access and nearby public transportation.
- Weather resilience: A great indoor activity, ideal for winter or rainy days.
An Honest Look at the Broadway Magic Hour

The Broadway Magic Hour is designed to entertain families and magic enthusiasts alike. Hosted at The Broadway Comedy Club, the show blends mind-reading, illusions, comedy, and audience participation into a lively 90-minute performance. You won’t get the same “prestige illusion” extravaganza as at a Las Vegas show, but what you will get is a very engaging, fun-filled experience that keeps children and adults smiling.
You can also read our reviews of more tours and experiences in New York City
The Itinerary Breakdown
The show begins promptly at 2:00 pm, making it a perfect midday break or a way to relax after a morning of sightseeing. You’ll find yourself in a cozy, theatrical setting where the magicians, Jim Vines and Carl Mercurio, take center stage. Their style is witty and approachable, making the magic accessible and amusing, especially for a family audience.
The magic tricks range from grand illusions to mind-reading feats and audience participation, which means you might find yourself called up to assist or be part of the show. Several reviews highlight how kids love the interaction and how the humor is suited to a younger crowd, but still enjoyable for adults. One reviewer mentioned, “The magicians were super funny and engaging,” which speaks to their ability to connect with all ages.
Audience Experience
Most guests find the show astonishing and hilarious. One reviewer said, “The tricks and illusions were astonishing,” which suggests some surprises are genuinely impressive, even if some tricks are familiar to seasoned magic fans. The performers’ personalities add to the fun, making the event memorable.
Another key point is the audience participation, which many reviews highlight as a favorite aspect. Kids and adults alike get a chance to be part of the magic, making the experience interactive and lively. The show’s tone is primarily light-hearted, with a focus on fun rather than mystique, ensuring everyone leaves with a smile.
What’s Included and What’s Not
The ticket, priced at $25, covers general admission. It’s a straightforward, budget-friendly price for high-quality family entertainment. Snacks and drinks are available for purchase at The Broadway Comedy Club but are not included in the ticket price. The venue offers ADA compliance, elevator access, and nearby public transportation, making it accessible for most visitors.
Review Highlights: What Visitors Love
Multiple reviews praise the show for its entertaining tricks and kid-friendly humor. One said, “My kids enjoyed the show thoroughly,” and another shared, “The magicians were super funny and engaging,” emphasizing the performers’ ability to entertain across generations. Even those who felt some tricks were predictable acknowledged the fun atmosphere and witty personalities of the magicians.
A visitor also pointed out the convenience of arriving early if they wanted to volunteer, which adds a layer of interactive fun not always available at magic shows. The show’s affordable price point also gets high marks, especially considering the quality of entertainment.
- 4-Hour Public Sopranos Sites Bus Tour
- 4.5-Hour City Tour: Statue of Liberty, 9/11 Memorial, Wall Street
- 911 Ground Zero Tour & Museum Preferred Access
- 9/11 Memorial, Ground Zero Tour With Optional One World Observatory Ticket
- 9/11 Memorial, Ground Zero Tour With Optional 9/11 Museum Ticket
- 9/11 Memorial Museum Admission Ticket
Is It Worth the Price?
Considering the tickets cost only $25, the value here is quite good. You get a well-paced, family-oriented show that’s not only fun but also easy to fit into a day of sightseeing. While some tricks may be familiar to seasoned magicians, the show’s lively delivery and audience engagement make it worth the price for most families.
Practical Tips for Visitors

- Arrive early if you want to be a volunteer or to secure seats close to the stage.
- Plan around this show if you’re in Times Square – it’s near many other attractions and easy to add to your itinerary.
- Consider adding some snacks or drinks from the venue’s menu for a full experience.
- The show’s timing allows you to combine it with other afternoon activities or sightseeing.
- If you’re concerned about accessibility, note that the venue is ADA compliant with elevator access and ADA bathrooms.
Who Will Love This Show?
This magic show is especially suitable for families with young children, around ages 6 and up, who enjoy interactive, lively entertainment. It’s a perfect rainy-day activity or a fun break during a busy sightseeing day. Adults looking for light comedy mixed with magic will find it amusing, and grandparents often report enjoying the show just as much as the kids.
While it’s not a high-end illusion spectacle, the affordable price and accessible location make it a smart choice for many looking to add some joy and wonder to their NYC visit without breaking the bank.
Final Thoughts

If you’re seeking a fun, engaging, family-friendly activity in the heart of Manhattan, the Broadway Magic Hour offers a good mix of magic tricks, comedy, and audience interaction—all at a wallet-friendly price. The show’s location near Times Square makes it easy to incorporate into your day, and its accessible features ensure everyone can enjoy the fun.
While some tricks are familiar, the performers’ warm personalities and lively style keep the energy high and the mood joyful. It’s a great value for families wanting to introduce their children to magic or simply enjoy some lighthearted entertainment in an energetic, theatrical setting.
This experience is best suited for families, groups of kids, or anyone looking for a wholesome, indoor activity that’s sure to generate smiles and amazement. Whether it’s for a rainy day or an afternoon break, the Broadway Magic Hour makes for a memorable, inexpensive addition to your New York City adventure.
FAQ

Is there a specific age range for this show?
The show is geared toward children aged 6 and older, but audiences of all ages seem to enjoy the lively, comedic atmosphere.
How long is the show?
The performance lasts approximately 1 hour and 30 minutes, making it a perfect midday activity.
What’s included in the ticket price?
Your ticket covers general admission for the magic show. Snacks and drinks are available for purchase but are not included.
Is the venue accessible?
Yes, the Broadway Comedy Club is ADA compliant, with elevator access and ADA bathrooms nearby.
Can I cancel my ticket?
Yes, cancellations are free if made at least 24 hours in advance, with full refunds issued.
What is the location like?
The show takes place at The Broadway Comedy Club near Times Square, an easily accessible venue close to public transportation.
Is this show suitable for adults without children?
Absolutely. Many reviews mention that adults find it hilarious and engaging, especially those who enjoy magic and comedy.
Is there audience participation?
Yes, audience members are often called upon for tricks or to participate, adding to the fun.
What if I want to arrive early?
Arriving early may increase your chances of volunteering or getting better seats.
Are there any hidden costs?
No, the ticket price is all-inclusive for the show. Extras are for snacks or drinks purchased on-site.
The Broadway Magic Hour provides a light, joyful experience that makes it a smart choice for families and those looking for a fun, engaging indoor activity during a busy day in New York City.
More Shows & Entertainment in New York City
More Tour Reviews in New York City
Not for you? Here's more nearby things to do in New York City we have reviewed
- New York City: Private Professional Photoshoot
- New York City Breakfast and Sites
- 7 Days Small Group Tour to Visit Top Schools from NYC
- VIP All Access Empire State Building and Manhattan Walking Tour
- Dyker Heights Holiday Lights Tour Christmas Magic in NYC
- NYC: Greenwich Village Food Tour
- 3 Hour Lower Manhattan Walking Tour
- Airport Transfer: New York to Newark Airport EWR by Business Car
- NYC Dark History Walking Tour: Ghosts, Murders, and Mafia
- Central Park NYC Family Photoshoot – Memories in the Heart of NYC
- Broadway Backstage: From Times Square to Studio
- Washington DC from New York 1 Day
