Welcome to Our Review of The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl in Williamsburg

If you’re visiting Williamsburg and craving an experience that steps beyond the typical historic tours, the Murder Tour and Pub Crawl offers a compelling mix of true crime stories, local history, and social fun. This experience is perfect for those intrigued by the darker side of history but who also enjoy a relaxed, social atmosphere. We particularly appreciate how it combines storytelling with visits to three well-chosen local watering holes, making it more than just a walking lecture.
Two things stand out about this tour: first, the knowledgeable guides who deliver the stories with enthusiasm and clarity, and second, the excellent selection of wines and beers that add a touch of sophistication to an otherwise macabre theme.
A possible drawback? The tour’s focus on murder stories means it might feel a bit intense or grim for sensitive travelers or children. It’s designed for adults who enjoy a good story with their libation and a bit of spooky ambiance. If you’re a history buff with a taste for true crime or simply looking for a unique evening in Williamsburg, this tour could be a great choice.
Key Points
- Balanced blend of history, crime stories, and social drinking
- Engaging guides bring stories to life with local insight
- Three carefully selected pubs provide relaxed breaks and quality drinks
- Authentic storytelling with at least 12 murder stories told (per reviews)
- Cost reflects value with three drinks included and a three-hour experience
- Suitable for adults interested in dark history and lively social settings
You can also read our reviews of more nightlife experiences in Williamsburg
What You Can Expect from the Tour

The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl in Williamsburg is a well-crafted 3-hour journey that weaves together true crime stories with visits to some of the town’s popular drinking spots. Starting at the specified meeting point, you’ll be guided on foot through the historic streets, with the stories gradually revealing Williamsburg’s sinister past.
This isn’t a ghostly haunt; it’s about the real, often grisly crimes that left their mark on the city. The stories are drawn from actual events, and according to reviews, you’ll hear at least a dozen tales of murder and hatred that took place in this old town. Several guests have praised the guide’s storytelling skills, highlighting how they make history feel alive and relevant.
The Itinerary Breakdown
Stop 1: Precarious Beer Project
Your evening kicks off here with a 30-minute visit to this local brewery, where you can enjoy a drink of your choice. The brewery’s relaxed vibe makes it a great place to start soaking in the atmosphere. It’s a good way to settle in and get comfortable before the stories begin, and the included drink helps set the tone for the evening.
Stop 2: Williamsburg Winery Tasting Room and Wine Bar
Next, you’ll hop over to the Merchant Square area for a 30-minute wine tasting. Reviewers have noted the excellent wine selection, and the ambiance here adds an elegant touch to the experience. It’s also a chance to chat with your fellow participants and get into the mood for some darker tales.
Stop 3: The Hound’s Tale
The third stop is a cozy pub where you’ll enjoy your third 30-minute drink break. The guide will share more chilling stories as you sip on whatever specialty beverage you choose. The guide’s storytelling is often highlighted as a tour highlight—engaging, humorous, and informative.
Final Segment: The Guided Walking Tour
The last 1.5 hours are dedicated to walking through historic Williamsburg, where your guide recounts true crime stories that took place in the city’s streets. The balance of storytelling and strolling allows you to absorb the atmosphere while learning about the city’s shadowy past.
The Experience: Drinks, Stories, and Historic Streets

One aspect many reviews agree on is the quality of the guide. Participants rave about how knowledgeable and engaging the guide is, making the tour feel more like a storytelling evening rather than a lecture. The stories are not only about murder but also include interesting facts that add depth to Williamsburg’s history.
The three included drinks—which can be from the pub’s options—offer a welcome pause between stories. Several guests have highlighted the excellent wine choices at the tasting room and the friendly atmosphere of the pubs. This makes the tour feel fun and relaxed rather than dark and gloomy, even though the subject matter is intense.
The walking portion is moderate, and some reviews suggest that the pace is comfortable, though a reviewer with mobility issues noted that the walking might be a bit much if physical ailments limit movement. The tour lasts about three hours, making it an ideal evening activity for those looking for something different.
The Value and Cost

With a price of $48 per person, the tour offers a solid value when you consider the three drinks included and the storytelling experience. The tour’s reviews suggest that many find it worth the cost, especially considering the quality of the guides and the unique blend of history and entertainment.
Some reviewers noted that the tour’s stories are more numerous than might initially seem apparent; one mentioned that there are at least 12 murder stories told, making the experience feel substantial. The inclusion of drinks at three local establishments adds a social element that many find enjoyable.
You can also read our reviews of more drinking tours in Williamsburg
Who Should Consider This Tour?

This experience is best suited for adults who appreciate a mix of history, crime stories, and social drinking. It’s ideal for those wanting to explore Williamsburg’s darker side without the ghostly overtones common in other tours. If you enjoy engaging storytelling and a lively pub crawl, you’ll likely find this tour to be a highlight.
However, if you’re seeking a purely historical overview or a leisurely walk without the crime focus, other Williamsburg tours might be more fitting. Also, keep in mind that the tour is non-refundable and depends on good weather, so plan accordingly.
Final Thoughts

The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl in Williamsburg offers a unique twist on exploring the city’s storied streets. Instead of wandering through historic sites and listening to dry facts, you’ll be immersed in true crime stories that reveal a darker, more sinister side of Williamsburg’s past. The inclusion of three well-chosen pubs, each with quality drinks, makes it a lively and social way to spend an evening.
The guided storytelling, combined with the relaxed pub stops, makes it perfect for those who enjoy engaging narratives, a bit of history, and a glass of wine or beer in hand. It’s an experience that balances entertainment with education, and the reviews suggest it consistently delivers an enjoyable, memorable night out.
In short, if you’re curious about Williamsburg’s dark history, want to enjoy some good drinks, and appreciate a knowledgeable guide, this tour should be on your list.
FAQ

Is this tour suitable for children?
No, this tour is designed for adults because of its mature themes involving murder and crime stories.
How long does the tour last?
It lasts approximately 3 hours, inclusive of stops and walking through the streets.
Are the drinks included in the price?
Yes, the tour includes three drinks of your choosing at the pubs and wineries visited.
Is the tour accessible for people with mobility issues?
The tour involves walking through historic streets, so those with mobility concerns should consider this before booking.
Can I choose different drinks at each stop?
The tour provides a choice of drinks at each stop, but specific options might depend on what’s available at each hotel.
What should I wear?
Comfortable walking shoes are recommended, as you’ll be strolling through historic streets during the storytelling segment.
What happens if the weather is bad?
The experience requires good weather and may be canceled if conditions are unsuitable. You’ll be offered a different date or a full refund if canceled due to weather.
In Closing

The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl offers a distinctive way to experience Williamsburg, combining spine-tingling stories with a casual pub crawl. It’s a great pick for adults who enjoy history, crime, and socializing in a relaxed setting. The knowledgeable guides, paired with quality drinks, make it a memorable evening for those looking to see a different side of this historic town.
Whether you’re a history lover, a true crime aficionado, or just seeking a fun, different night out, this tour gives you a chance to explore Williamsburg’s darker tales without sacrificing a good time. Just remember to book in advance—this experience tends to be popular—and come ready for an evening of stories, sips, and some of Williamsburg’s most intriguing corners.
More Nightlife Experiences in Williamsburg
More Tours in Williamsburg
More Tour Reviews in Williamsburg
Not for you? Here's more nearby things to do in Williamsburg we have reviewed
- Virginia Historic Adventure!
- Gallows Path Ghost Tour
- Signature Ride at Upper Shirley Vineyards – 3 hours
- Scavenger Hunt Adventure in Williamsburg by Operation City Quest
- Williamsburg’s Famous Ghosts Self Guided Audio Walking Tour
- Night Watchman’s Ghost Tour
- Private Tour From Williamsburg to Monticello World Heritage Site
- Williamsburg Family Trek A Journey Through Time and Tales
- Tales of Christmas Past and Present in Williamsburg
- Secret Lives on Colonial Women
- Williamsburg’s Winter Wonderland: A Historic Holiday Stroll
- What Says Virginia: A Question of Independence Review
