Lunch at Iconic Redeye Grill near Central Park and Carnegie Hall!

A Taste of New York: Lunch at Redeye Grill near Carnegie Hall

When exploring the city that never sleeps, sometimes a good meal is all it takes to refresh and refocus. This review covers an appealing option for those who want to experience a classic New York eatery without breaking the bank: a two-course prix-fixe lunch at Redeye Grill. Located directly across from Carnegie Hall and just a short walk from Broadway, this spot offers more than just a meal — it’s a chance to soak in the city’s vibrant dining scene.

What we love about this experience is its convenient Midtown location, perfect for those spending their day sightseeing or catching a show. The diversity of the menu means there’s something for all—from sushi lovers to steak enthusiasts. Plus, the price point of $41, which includes gratuities and tax, packs a lot of value for a sit-down lunch with a choice of well-prepared dishes.

That said, it’s not a lengthy experience; at about 90 minutes, it caters well to folks on a tight schedule, but this might be a downside if you’re looking for a leisurely, extended meal. Also, since the package includes only soft drinks, those wanting alcohol will need to consider their additional costs. Still, for a quick, quality bite in a lively neighborhood, Redeye Grill hits the mark.

This experience suits travelers who want a taste of New York’s culinary style without the fuss of a full dinner. It’s also great for those who appreciate prime Midtown locations and prefer an easy, no-fuss booking with a mobile ticket. Whether you’re heading to a Broadway show or just need a dependable lunch spot, Redeye Grill offers a straightforward, tasty option.

Key Points

• Prime Midtown Location: Right across from Carnegie Hall, close to Broadway, making it ideal for theater-goers or sightseeing groups.
• Two-Course Prix-Fixe: Includes an appetizer and entrée, with options like sushi, salads, steaks, and seafood.
• Affordable and Convenient: At $41, with gratuities and tax included, it provides good value for quality American brasserie dining.
• Time-Efficient: The 1.5-hour schedule fits neatly into busy sightseeing plans or pre-theater meals.
• Inclusive of Soft Drink: The package includes a fountain soda or water, with alcohol available separately for those 21+.
• Mobile Ticketing: Easy to book and access, streamlining the check-in process in a bustling city environment.

The Experience in Detail

Location and Atmosphere
Redeye Grill’s location is one of its biggest draws. Sitting directly across from Carnegie Hall, the restaurant benefits from a prime Midtown address with easy access to nearby landmarks. Inside, it’s a lively yet comfortable place, blending the charm of a classic American brasserie with a touch of urban sophistication. The decor hints at a timeless New York vibe, while the bustling atmosphere is perfect for a quick business lunch or a pre-show meal.

The Menu and Food Quality
The menu offers a well-curated selection that promises a bit of everything. The appetizer choices include classics like Caesar Salad or something a little more adventurous like Fried Calamari served with yuzu aioli. The shrimp cocktail is also highlighted in reviews, indicating its popularity.

For the main course, options like Black Label Cheeseburger with Tillamook cheddar or the Grilled Teriyaki Salmon Bowl with spinach and brown rice cater to different tastes. The vegetarian teriyaki bowl ensures plant-based diners aren’t left out. The variety means you can plan your meal around your craving or dietary preference, which is helpful when on a tight schedule.

The inclusion of locally sourced fish, sushi, and fresh produce reflects a commitment to quality. Several reviews mention the freshness of ingredients and the well-executed flavors—important factors when choosing a quick lunch spot that still aims for quality.

Service and Group Size
With a maximum of 10 travelers per booking, this tour feels intimate and manageable. The staff is generally praised for their friendly, efficient service, which is crucial in a fast-paced environment like Midtown Manhattan. The convenience of a mobile ticket means you can skip the lines, making the process smooth and straightforward.

Timing and Pricing
The scheduled hours from 12:00 PM to 2:30 PM on weekdays are perfect for a midday break. The price of $41 includes a two-course meal, a soft drink, gratuities, and tax, making it a transparent and hassle-free option. This all-in-one package offers good value compared to individual restaurant prices, especially considering the prime location.

What Travelers Say
While reviews are still accumulating, the positive comments point to a dependable dining experience. Travelers appreciate the quality of the food, convenient location, and ease of booking. Some note that the lunch options are thoughtfully prepared, and the ability to sit right across from Carnegie Hall makes for a memorable meal.

Considerations
One potential drawback is that the experience is relatively brief, making it less ideal for those wanting a leisurely meal. Also, since alcohol isn’t included, those wanting a drink to accompany their meal will need to budget extra.

Who Should Consider This Tour?

This lunch experience is best suited for travelers who want a quick, quality meal in Midtown without sacrificing authenticity or convenience. It’s perfect for those attending a Broadway show, visiting Carnegie Hall, or simply needing a reliable spot to refuel during sightseeing. It’s also a smart choice for business travelers or groups who prefer a streamlined booking process and predictable pricing. If you’re looking for a solid, no-nonsense lunch in a lively setting—this is your ticket.

Final Thoughts: Is It Worth It?

For the value and location, Redeye Grill offers a dependable, tasty, and efficient lunch option. The menu’s diversity makes it likely everyone in your group will find something to enjoy, from seafood lovers to burger fans. The price point is fair for Midtown and the quality you’ll receive, especially with the inclusion of gratuities and tax.

However, if you’re someone who wants a more relaxed, lengthy meal or plans to indulge in alcohol, you might find this experience a bit limited. Still, if your goal is a good meal without fuss, and you’re in a hurry or near Broadway and Carnegie Hall, this tour ticks many boxes.

Overall, Redeye Grill’s lunch provides a taste of classic New York dining in an unbeatable location—perfect for travelers seeking efficiency, quality, and authenticity in the heart of Manhattan.

FAQ

Is this experience suitable for large groups?
This tour is designed for smaller groups, with a maximum of 10 travelers, ensuring personalized service and a more intimate atmosphere.

Can I include alcohol with this lunch?
Alcoholic beverages are not included in the package. Guests must be 21+ to purchase alcohol separately if desired.

What is the duration of the lunch?
The experience lasts about 1 hour 30 minutes, making it ideal for a quick yet satisfying meal during a busy day.

Is the booking process complicated?
No, the experience offers a mobile ticket, which makes booking and venue access straightforward and contactless.

What’s included in the price?
The $41 fee covers a two-course pre-fixe lunch, a soft drink or water, gratuities, and government taxes, providing a clear, all-in-one price.

What are the opening hours?
The experience runs Monday through Friday from 12:00 PM to 2:30 PM, aligning well with lunch hours in Midtown Manhattan.

How close is the restaurant to public transportation?
Redeye Grill is near public transportation, making it easy to reach from most parts of Manhattan, whether you’re coming from a hotel, Broadway, or other Midtown attractions.

If you’re looking for a practical, flavorful, and well-located lunch during your NYC visit, Redeye Grill offers a dependable choice that balances quality and convenience. It’s a chance to enjoy a classic American brasserie experience right when you need it—quick, tasty, and right in the heart of the city.