New York City: Prohibition Walking Tour – With Drinks

If you’re curious about the hidden past of New York City during Prohibition, this Prohibition Walking Tour with Drinks offers a lively and immersive glimpse into the city’s underworld. Designed for history buffs, cocktail lovers, and those who appreciate authentic city stories, this tour promises a balanced mix of storytelling, historic ambiance, and a few well-crafted drinks.

What we particularly like about this experience is how it makes history tangible—visiting real, historic saloons that once hosted mobsters and politicians, and hearing stories that bring the gritty 1920s to life. Plus, the inclusion of prohibition-style cocktails and beers at each stop adds a fun, flavorful element to the journey.

A possible consideration is the tour’s focus on historical storytelling and drinks; if you’re expecting a more in-depth exploration of NYC’s broader history or a quieter, more contemplative experience, this might feel a bit lively and on the social side.

This tour is best suited for travelers who enjoy a good story, appreciate historic ambiance, and are comfortable walking and standing for about two hours. It’s perfect for those looking for a lively, engaging way to experience a lesser-known chapter of NYC’s past.

Key Points

• Historic Saloons: Visit three of New York’s oldest and most iconic bars, each with its own story.
• Expert Guide: Knowledgeable guides bring tales of gangsters, bootleggers, and political corruption vividly to life.
• Included Drinks: Enjoy a beer or a Prohibition-style cocktail at each stop, adding a fun tasting element.
• Storytelling Focus: Learn about Tammany Hall, speakeasies, and infamous figures who shaped the city’s underworld.
• Authentic Atmosphere: Experience the ambiance of historic bars that have seen New York’s gritty past firsthand.
• Flexible and Practical: The tour lasts just 2 hours, usually in the afternoon, making it easy to fit into your NYC itinerary.

You can check availability for your dates here:

A Deep Dive into the Experience

Overview and Format

This 2-hour walking tour begins at the iconic Great Hall of Cooper Union, a historic venue steeped in political and cultural significance. From there, you’ll stroll through the city streets, passing through neighborhoods that once thrived with clandestine bars and criminal activity. The tour is designed for those 21 and over, and you should plan to arrive 15 minutes early to meet your guide.

The tour is operated by Forty Thieves Tours, a provider known for engaging, lively historical experiences. The group size tends to be small enough to foster conversation but large enough to keep the atmosphere energetic.

Visiting the Historic Saloons

You’ll visit three of New York’s oldest saloons, each chosen for their storied past and authentic atmosphere. These aren’t tourist traps but real, historic venues that have weathered decades—some dating back to the Prohibition era or earlier.

At each spot, you’re treated to a drink—whether a classic beer or a specially crafted Prohibition-style cocktail. These drinks are included in the $89 price, adding value and giving you a taste of what patrons drank during the roaring twenties. The guides help set the scene, describing how these saloons served as hubs for organized crime, political scheming, and social gathering.

The Stories and Atmosphere

Your guide, who has been praised for their knowledge and personable style, will regale you with tales of notorious gangsters, bootleggers, and corrupt politicians linked to campaigns like Tammany Hall. These stories are lively and often amusing—think mobsters hiding in plain sight and law enforcement turning a blind eye.

One reviewer raves, “Earl was fantastic! Very knowledgeable and personable.” This indicates you’re likely to get a guide who makes the history engaging and relatable. Expect anecdotes about figures like mobsters and political figures who shaped the city’s underbelly.

The ambiance of each saloon adds another layer. These venues often still retain their vintage decor, creaky wood, and period details, which make the experience feel authentic. The combination of stories and setting makes it clear how these bars served as more than just drinking spots—they were key players in New York’s secret history.

More Great Tours Nearby

Ending at a Legendary Saloon

The tour culminates at what’s described as New York’s most legendary saloon, where you’ll toast to the city’s wild past. This final stop offers a sense of closure and a chance to reflect on what you’ve learned while enjoying your included drink.

Who Will Love This Tour?

This experience is ideal for travelers who want a short, engaging, and social way to learn about NYC’s Prohibition history. Fans of American gangster stories, cocktail connoisseurs, and those interested in the city’s political scandals will find plenty to enjoy.

It’s also suited for those who appreciate small-group tours, as the guide’s storytelling style creates an intimate and lively atmosphere. Plus, the included drinks and walk through historic neighborhoods add a sensory layer that makes the past feel alive and immediate.

The Value and Practical Considerations

At $89 per person, the tour offers a compelling mix of history, atmosphere, and drinks. Visiting three historic saloons and listening to expert storytelling provides a more immersive experience than simply reading about Prohibition. The drinks included at each stop maximize the value, especially for those eager to sample period-style cocktails.

The duration of 2 hours makes it manageable for most travelers, fitting easily into an afternoon agenda. However, be prepared for some walking and standing—wear comfortable shoes and plan for the weather, as the tour is outdoors and involves street strolls.

Accessibility and Logistics

Since the tour starts at the Great Hall of Cooper Union, which is relatively central, logistics are straightforward. It’s a 21+ experience, so only those with valid ID can participate. If you’re traveling with mobility issues, this might not be suitable, as it involves walking and standing on city streets.

Reviews and Guides

Based on the reviews, guides like Earl receive high praise for their storytelling ability and personable approach. One review mentions it felt like visiting old bars with a friend, emphasizing the relaxed and friendly vibe. The enthusiasm and knowledge of guides significantly enhance the experience, making history feel vivid and personal.

Final Thoughts: Who Should Book?

This walking tour offers a fun, lively peek into a secret chapter of New York’s past. If you enjoy history with a side of storytelling, appreciate vintage ambiance, and want to sample period-appropriate drinks, this is a fantastic choice. It’s particularly suited for those who love engaging guides and small-group experiences.

While it doesn’t cover every aspect of NYC’s history, it excels at portraying the colorful, criminal, and political side of the city during Prohibition. It’s an affordable, memorable way to deepen your understanding of NYC’s complex personality—one cocktail at a time.

FAQ

Is this tour suitable for non-drinkers?
This tour is designed around enjoying drinks at each stop, with one included at every location. If you don’t drink alcohol, you might find the experience less appealing, but you could still enjoy the history and ambiance.

How long does the tour last?
The tour lasts approximately 2 hours, making it a manageable activity to fit into an afternoon or early evening.

Where does the tour start?
It begins at the Great Hall of Cooper Union, a historic venue. You should arrive 15 minutes before the scheduled start time to meet your guide.

Are there any age restrictions?
Yes, participants must be 21 or older, with valid ID required. It’s not suitable for minors or those with mobility impairments.

How many saloons will we visit?
You will visit three of the city’s oldest and most iconic saloons, each with a distinct story and atmosphere.

What’s included in the price?
The price covers three drinks—either a beer or a Prohibition-style cocktail—and the guided walking experience.

Is tipping customary?
While not explicitly mentioned, tipping guides for good service is customary and appreciated, especially given their engaging storytelling.

If you’re after an energetic, historically rooted experience that combines storytelling, authentic venues, and a taste of the past, this Prohibition Walking Tour hits the mark. It offers a spirited way to explore a lesser-known side of New York City, revealing how the city’s underbelly operated during its most clandestine era.

Perfect for history lovers, cocktail enthusiasts, and curious travelers alike, it’s a memorable addition to any NYC trip—adding flavor, fun, and fascinating tales to your visit. Just remember to dress comfortably and arrive ready to enjoy stories, sips, and the city’s vibrant streets.

You can check availability for your dates here: More Great Tours Nearby